You are reading ©Deirdre McCloskey's Bourgeois Dignity: Why Economics Can't Explain the Modern World, draft (July 2009).
Table of contents. | JOURNAL HOME | This is a print-ready HTML document | Word version: n/a.
Deirdre Nansen McCloskey | Bourgeois Dignity, July 2009 version
COPYRIGHTED MATERIAL | University of Chicago Press, 2010


A list of all the Not Causes discussed in Bourgeois Dignity and Liberty: Why Economics Can’t Explain the Modern World

Background Conditions, Good or Bad, of All Eurasian Civilizations before 1500, Which Merely Intensified Later

  • Literary, artistic, and scientific flowering
  • Respect for learning; universities
  • Education of elite
  • Printing and paper
  • Compass
  • Clocks [but especially in Europe]
  • Monotheism [especially in Europe including Orthodoxy, and in Muslim world]
  • Peace and bourgeois prosperity [less in Europe]
  • Urbanization [less so in northern Europe]
  • (-? or +?) High death rates in cities
  • Competent bureaucracy [especially in China]
  • High seed/yield ratios [not in Europe, which did not have much rice, or any maize]
  • Investment capability [less so in Europe: see yield/seed ratio]
  • Wide long-distance trade [less so in Europe]
  • Slavery and its trade [especially in Middle East]
  • Wide and deep internal trade and markets
  • Good internal transportation, especially unimproved rivers, canals, and coastal ships
  • Temperate climate
  • (-) Onset of Little Ice Age (1300-1850) after climatic maximum before 1300
  • (-) Malaria
  • (-? or +?) The Plague
  • Desire for profit
  • Rule of law
  • Property rights
  • Money [in China even paper money]
  • Reasonably sophisticated financial institutions
  • High incomes in a few favored places
  • Coal widely used [China, India, Europe]

Incidental Events 1500 to the Present, Not Contributing Much to the Great Fact

  • Protestant ethic
  • Thrift
  • Rise of rationality
  • Rise of greed
  • Spanish and Portuguese imperialism
  • The Price Revolution
  • Dutch, British, French trade (except as contributing to bourgeois dignity)
  • Dutch, British, French imperialism
  • Slave trade
  • Rises in the rate of saving
  • Original accumulation of capital
  • Surplus value, reinvestment
  • Routine investment
  • Exploitation of the working class
  • Science (until around 1900)
  • (-) Sustained high prestige of aristocracy and gentry
  • Routine transportation improvement (canals, harbors)
  • English genetics
  • English social inheritance
  • Stuart missteps and taxation
  • The Glorious Revolution
  • Institutional change